Lottery and the Public Interest

Lottery is a game where participants pay a small fee to select a group of numbers, or have machines randomly select them for them, and win a prize if their number matches those selected by the machine. It is a form of gambling, but it has received considerable public approval because it involves no onerous taxes on the poor and working class. However, state governments are increasingly dependent on lottery revenues, and critics have argued that the promotion of gambling is at cross-purposes with the public interest.

The casting of lots to determine decisions and fates has a long history, with the first recorded public lottery being held in the Low Countries in the 15th century to raise money for town fortifications and help the needy. During the American Revolution, Benjamin Franklin used a lottery to fund cannons for Philadelphia. George Washington sponsored a lottery in 1768 to finance the construction of roads across the Blue Ridge Mountains. Modern lottery games, which usually involve a small ticket costing a dollar or less, are regulated by state law and provide an alternative to a sales tax.

In the early years of the post-World War II era, state governments found it much easier to expand their array of social safety net programs than they had previously, because they could draw on a new source of revenue that was not especially burdensome to middle and working class taxpayers. This arrangement came to an end with the rise of inflation and the Vietnam War.

Since the 1970s, there have been numerous innovations in lottery offerings. Most of these have aimed to increase and maintain lottery revenues, which had expanded rapidly after the first lotteries were introduced, but are now flat or falling. New game introductions have included scratch-off tickets and “quick pick” numbers, which eliminate the need for players to individually select their own numbers.

Critics charge that lottery advertising is deceptive, presenting misleading information about the odds of winning the jackpot; inflating the value of prizes (lottery winners often receive their prize in installments over 20 years, with inflation and taxes dramatically eroding the current value); encouraging compulsive gamblers by promising them that they can overcome their problems by spending more; and promoting gambling as an attractive option for the poor and working class because it provides an opportunity to gain wealth quickly.

The argument that lottery is an acceptable way for state governments to increase spending without increasing taxes on the rich and middle classes is based on the premise that the profits generated by a lottery are entirely self-generating, because the players are voluntarily spending their own money on chance. But this premise is not always valid, and in some cases may even be harmful to the public interest. This is especially true if the lottery promotes gambling to lower-income groups, and encourages them to spend more than they can afford to lose.